Investigative Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best example of investigative reporting in the public interest, either in a single story or a series.
First Place: "Flawed and Sometimes Deadly: Military Medicine System Leaves Lives Shattered by Substandard Care," Russell Carollo and Jeff Nesmith, The Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "An impressive, exhaustive and compelling series, combining clear presentation with specific and significant findings. The worth of the series can be at least partly judged by the significance of the results."
Second Place (tie): "Transplanting Life: The Triumphs, The Traps, The Tragedies," Dave Davis, Joan Mazzolini and Ted Wendling, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "A very important series about a problem any of us might face. Human interest narratives in the series were particularly poignant."
Second Place (tie): "Up in Arms," John Michael Kelly, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "This series challenges conventional wisdom, pointing out there has been considerable media hype concerning the patriot movement."

Best Public Journalism—This prize is awarded to the best example of public journalism. "Public journalism" is defined as an effort by a publication or journalist to connect with the community in a different way, either by encouraging civic participation or otherwise regrounding the publication's coverage of politics.
First Place: "Judgment on Schools: What's Next?," Doug Oplinger, Dennis J. Willard, James C. Benton, Seth Daniel, Margaret Newkirk, Michael Racey, Arnie Rosenberg, Lornet Turnbull, Mary Ethridge, Ed Meyer, Keith McKnight, Melanie Payne, Steve Hoffman, Paula Schleis, Barbara Galloway, and Kim Hone-McMahan (reporters), Mizell Stewart III, Bonnie Bolden, Mary Beth Breckenridge, Geoff Gevalt, David Hertz, Michelle LeComte, Roger Mezger, and Bob Paynter (editors), The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "Being told by the Supreme Court to fix the schools is a tough task. This project on schools makes it a bit easier for readers to understand by explaining all of the decision's ramifications."
Second Place: "Akron Speaks Up," Bob Dyer, Keith McKnight, Bill O'Connor, R.D. Heldenfels, James C. Benton, Kim Hone-McMahan, Melanie Payne, Carl Chancellor, William Canterbury, Carole Cannon, Sallie Cook, Stephen Dyer, Diane Evans, Janet Frankston, Glenn Gamboa, Andale Gross, Kymberli Hagelberg, John Higgins, Desiree F. Hicks, Steve Hoffman, Robert Hoiles, Ron Kirksey, David Knox, Gregory Korte, Betty Lin-Fisher, Dennis McEaneney, Ed Myer, Charlene Nevada, Margaret Newkirk, Amy Reis, Arnie Rosenberg, Thrity Umrigar, Tracy Wheeler and Regina Brett, (reporters), Geoff Gevalt, Michelle LeComte, Bonnie Bolden, Roger Mezger, Bob Paynter, Mizell Stewart III, and Cristel Williams (editors), The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "Talking and writing about race relations isn't easy. This package, obviously highlighted by the President's visit, looks at many sides of the issues."

Best Database Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best use of a database or online source.
First Place: "Flawed and Sometimes Deadly: Military Medicine System Leaves Lives Shattered by Substandard Care," Russell Carollo and Jeff Nesmith, The Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "The Dayton Daily News created 20 databases of its own to dig out the names of military doctors who were involved in malpractice cases."
Second Place: "Transplanting Life: The Triumphs, The Traps, The Tragedies," Dave Davis, Joan Mazzolini and Ted Wendling, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "The Plain Dealer worked a database in order to show that transplant centers with a low volume of patients also had the highest death rates. The investigation also found wide disparities in the time patients wait for organs, and centers that frequently reject healthy organs for nonmedical reasons."

Best Coverage of Children's Issues—This prize is awarded to the story that best served the needs of children, either by exposing an abuse or exploring solutions to challenges faced by youth.
First Place: "Judgment Calls: A Case Study of the Child Welfare Process, From the Inside," Jean Dubail (reporter), Kevin O'Brien, Martha Mueller Neff and Pat McCubbin (editors), Milan Kecman (design), The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "Heart-wrenching stories, made more so by the graceful writing and excellent reporting."
Second Place: "When a Child Strikes Back," Regina Brett, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "A compelling series, nicely executed."

Best Coverage of the Environment—This prize is awarded to the story that best served to improve the environment, either by pointing out a trouble spot or otherwise spotlighting an ecological topic.
First Place: "The Clean Water Act at 25: Restoring Ohio's Rivers and Lakes," Randall Edwards and Tim Revell, The Columbus Dispatch. Judges' Comments: "How far has Ohio come in the 25 years since Congress passed the Clean Water Act? Reporter Randall Edwards and photographer Tim Revell set out on a nine-month journey to gauge the state's progress. A readable and well-researched effort."
Second Place: "From Septic Tanks to Ohio Farmland: The Problem of 'Septage'," Bob Downing, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "A solid effort in bringing a problem to light."

Best Medical/Science Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best coverage of a medical or science topic.
First Place: "Wired for Hope: Their Every Move Is Electric," Mike McIntyre and Joan Mazzolini, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "Captivating look at high-tech science, interspersing stories about real people. Fascinating."
Second Place: "The Shape of the Nation: The Weight Crisis in America," Jim DeBrosse, The Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "A look at the problem many face and the possible solutions."

Best Consumer Reporting—This prize is awarded to the story that best informs readers about a product flaw or danger, or otherwise befriends the consumer.
First Place: "Chasing a Contractor: Avoiding the Nightmare of Costly Legal Fights," Sheryl Harris, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "Interesting story. Problems with builders are always a concern. ... Nicely done."
Second Place: "Snapshots Enter the Digital Age: Photos Can Be Whatever You Imagine," Chuck Melvin, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "This story provides a real service to readers about a new digital technology."

Best Coverage of Minority Issues—This prize is awarded to the story that best addresses the issues and challenges faced by any minority group: racial, sexual, even religious.
First Place: "Growing Up Black," Mary Bridgman, The Columbus Dispatch. Judges' Comments: "An outstanding look at African-Americans' childhoods and how they got where they are today. Fine stories, well told."
Second Place: "Underground Railroad: Paths to Freedom," James Cummings, The Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "A wonderful series examining the history of the Underground Railroad and its impact in 1997."

Best Criminal Justice Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best reporting on crime or a law enforcement issue.
First Place: "Justice in Jeopardy: Judges, Legislator, Felons Linked," Wes Hills, Rob Modic and Jim Bebbington, The Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "This is the winner in an exceptionally impressive collection of entries. Well researched and tracked, it stands out because of its impact for change."
Second Place: "New Findings in the Dr. Sam Sheppard Murder," James F. McCarty, Michael Sangiacomo, Michael O'Malley, Mark Rollenhagen, Joe Dirck, and Doris O'Donnell, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "Wonderfully comprehensive treatment, across three days in February 1997, of the crime that won't stay solved. It's made even more impressive for its timelines and complex analysis."

Best Social Justice Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best reporting on a social justice issue (poverty, welfare).
First Place: "Special Report: Prostitution," Betsy Hiel, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "Statistics and anecdotes make this a fascinating series about a topic most people have an opinion on, but know little about it."
Second Place: "Fixing Welfare: Rural Ohio," Mary McCarty, The Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "Real people are highlighted to make the story real."

Best Explanatory Journalism—This prize is awarded to the best explanation to the reader of a complex topic.
First Place: "Unconstitutional: High Court's Ruling on School Funding," Duane St. Clair, Alan Johnson, Catherine Candisky, Lee Leonard, Rita Price, Jim Woods, Darrel Rowland, Mary Mogan Edwards, Carol Ann Lease, Don Baird, Ron Carter, Ruth Sternberg, Julie Bailey and Staff, The Columbus Dispatch. Judges' Comments: "Talk about a complex issue. Solid reporting and writing. All of the pieces are here."
Second Place: "Tax Breaks Often Prove to be Dangerous Deals," Sam Roe, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "Fascinating story. A good read."

Best Editorial Page Campaign—This prize is awarded to the best effort by an editorial page to correct an inadequacy at the state or local level. The entry may include unsigned editorials, columns and, if applicable, editorial cartoons and reader responses.
First Place: "Fixing Ohio's Schools: State's Future Is on the Line," The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "Complete doesn't begin to describe this campaign to fix Ohio schools."
Second Place: "Step Up and Save Jeep," The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "A strong editorial campaign, and it worked!"

Best Education Coverage—This prize is awarded to the best story about education.
First Place: "Public Schools, Public Views," Staff, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "A thoughtful, compelling and comprehensive exploration and explanation of a complicated subject. It was made enlightening and entertaining by a great mix of human stories."
Second Place: "School Funding Project," David Shutt, James Drew, Tom Troy, John Michael Kelly, L.A. Johnson, Mike Wilkinson, George J. Tanber and Michael D. Sallah, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "Well reported and well thought out. Solid looks at other states to give readers fine perspective."

Best Media Criticism—This prize is awarded to the best reporting on a media controversy or shortcoming of the press.
First Place: "Student's Actions Lead to Lesson in Media Attention," Christopher Borrelli, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "Terrific, specific account bringing media issues into perspective by focusing on coverage of a local controversy."
Second Place: "Media Worship of Diana Is Way Overdone: Her Death Is Sad, Yes. But Non-stop Fawning Undeserved," R. D. Heldenfels, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "Excellent commentary on how national and local media responded to biggest story of year."

Best Coverage of Government—This prize is awarded to the best story, or selection of stories, on city, county or state government.
First Place: "Special Report: Water, Water Everywhere, But Do the Hydrants Work?," Jeffrey Cohan, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "Cohan's stories explore the cavalier attitude of the Toledo city government toward public health and safety regarding the care of city fire hydrants."
Second Place: "Warning to Stow," Jim Quinn, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "Quinn reveals the extent and danger of religious bigotry in a community."

Best Human Interest Writing—This prize is awarded to the best single human interest feature.
First Place: "Robbie's Story: How A Fragile 14-year-old Boy Was Crushed in His Struggle To Accept Being Gay," Eleanor Mallet, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "A moving topic told in an equally moving manner."
Second Place: "Saga of the Hicks Babies: Sold Children Dig for Truth ... To Their Illegal Adoptions Over 30 Years Ago," Regina Brett, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "Great writing. A great story."

Best Personality Profile—This prize is awarded to the best single personality profile.
First Place: "The Diary of a Rapist," Michele Melendez and James F. McCarty, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "This pair of writers combined a fascinating personality profile with first-rate crime reporting. The result is a compelling look at a man who put fear into the lives of many in the Cleveland area. Excellent weaving of the investigative process with the thoughts in Liptak's head, as recorded in his journal."
Second Place (tie): "A League of His Own," Leah Weaver, Quest. Judges' Comments: "This profile succeeds in showing what Gordon Gee meant to the university and vice versa."
Second Place (tie): "Linked by Love," Connie Schultz, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "Endearing look at how two strong personalities in an interracial marriage rise in their careers, the social issues that drive them, and each other."

Best Business Coverage—This prize is awarded for the best business reporting (story or series).
First Place: "Secrets of a Deal: The Failed Attempt to Sell Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Ohio," Diane Solov and Mark Tatge, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "Outstanding! This is what newspaper journalism is supposed to be."
Second Place: "UPS: Covering the Strike," Sandra Livingston, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: None.

Best Sports Coverage—This prize is awarded to the best sports reporting (story or series)
First Place: "Select Sports: Push for Glory Begins Early," Susan Vinella, The Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "Solid, thorough and non-judgmental report on a subject that engages many and raises fundamental questions about issues that extend well beyond the playing fields."
Second Place: "Courageous First Steps/Breaking the Barriers: Jackie Robinson 50th Anniversary Commemorative Section," Geoff Hobson, Chris Haft, Tim Sullivan, John Erardi and Tom Groeschen, The Cincinnati Enquirer. Judges' Comments: "Wonderful presentation of possibly the No. 1 professional sports story of the century — encompassing both the issues and emotions involved and the broader impact the events had on our national life."

Best Arts Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best coverage (story or series) of an arts/entertainment topic.
First Place: "Making Tomorrow: Kids and Television," Julia Keller, The Columbus Dispatch. Judges' Comments: "What does television replace? To get a snapshot of how television affects children, the reporter weaved a chronicle of a fourth-grade class in the 1996-1997 school year with a discussion of the burgeoning electronic culture and whether the print media are doomed. Fascinating reading."
Second Place: "Van Cliburn International Piano Competition Coverage," Elaine Guregian, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "A story that follows the 'players' from start to finish."

Best Headline Writing—This prize is awarded to the best headline in 1997.
First Place: "Dog Market Soft in Spots: High-strung Dalmatians Hard to Give or Sell After Warnings," Peter Zicari, The Cleveland Plain Dealer. Judges' Comments: "Wonderful!"
Second Place: "P&G Floats An Ivory That Sinks" Phil Fisher, The Cincinnati Enquirer. Judges' Comments: "Clever, and conveys the idea well."

Best Web Site—This prize is awarded to the best single World Wide Web site run by a publication.
First Place: "Enquirer.com /GoCincinnati.com," James Jackson, Greg Noble, Ben Abes, James Bottorff and Jeff Tindall, The Cincinnati Enquirer. Judges' Comments: "Thoroughly professional newspaper site."
Second Place: "www.ohio.com," Staff, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "The site looks like it is lovingly constructed every day. Lots of local news — nice!"

Best Use of Public Record—This prize is awarded to the best use of the public record in researching a story.
First Place: "Flawed and Sometimes Deadly: Military Medicine System Leaves Lives Shattered by Substandard Care," Russell Carollo and Jeff Nesmith, The Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "The disclosures are sickening. Some military physicians have special Oklahoma medical licenses that do not even allow them to practice medicine in Oklahoma. Yet the military hires them to treat the U.S. fighting forces. The newspaper filed many FOIA requests and even went to federal court to get access to the records needed. The military to their eternal shame fought the disclosures."
Second Place: "Justice in Jeopardy: Judges, Legislator, Felons Linked," Wes Hills, Rob Modic and Jim Bebbington, Dayton Daily News. Judges' Comments: "Using local property records and state liquor records, the newspaper outlines a convoluted chain of ownership of a sports bar involving a judge, his wife (a state legislator) and various felons."

PRINT WINNERS (Under 100,000 Circulation)
Back to index

Best Investigative Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best example of investigative reporting in the public interest, either in a single story or a series.
First Place: "Gerald Lach Has a Dream. It's Not the First One," Monica Dias, The Kentucky Post. Judges' Comments: "A well-written piece on the financial impact of a developer's dream to build a 225-mile beltway into rural Kentucky. His plans for financing the road and his requests for money certainly raise questions and mistrust."
Second Place: "The Charity Trap," Randy Ludlow, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "Ludlow's three-part series on the skimming of charity dollars showed good enterprise and thorough coverage."

Best Public Journalism—This prize is awarded to the best example of public journalism. "Public journalism" is defined as an effort by a publication or journalist to connect with the community in a different way, either by encouraging civic participation or otherwise regrounding the publication's coverage of politics.
First Place: "A Plague of Guns," Sharon Turco, Gregory Korte, Joe Mosbrook Jr., Joyce McCartney, John Reynolds, Jim Vickers, Tom Germuska Jr., and Staff, Lorain Morning Journal. Judges' Comments: "Exhaustive work went into Guns for Groceries project that produced such tangible results. An exemplary effort that could be a model for those pursuing civic journalism."

Best Coverage of Children's Issues—This prize is awarded to the story that best serves the needs of children, either by exposing an abuse or exploring solutions to challenges faced by youth.
First Place: "From Drugs to Diploma: A Life Turned Around," Laurie Petrie, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "This story of a young man's success in overcoming a poor start is in and of itself an inspiration. The story of Terry Jones and his journey from the projects to Notre Dame is important and well-told."

Best Medical/Science Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best coverage of a medical or science topic.
First Place: "From Mice to Men," Dennis Breen, Cincinnati CityBeat. Judges' Comments: "With all the hype about so-called 'natural' miracle drugs, this story brings some perspective to the issue in a clear, understandable way."
Second Place: "Of Two Minds," Linda Vaccariello, Cincinnati Magazine. Judges' Comments: "Vaccariello does a nice job in making an old topic very timely, relevant and worth reading."

Best Consumer Reporting—This prize is awarded to the story that best informs readers about a consumer product flaw or danger, or otherwise befriends the consumer.
First Place: "Santa's Little Sweatshop: Do You Know Where Some of Your Christmas Clothes, Toys and Dolls Come From?," Marianne Salcetti, Cleveland Free Times. Judges' Comments: "Well-researched, important consumer information."
Second Place: "Safety First: A Valentine's Day Look at Condoms in Cowtown," Kim Leddy, Columbus Alive. Judges' Comments: "Frank discussion of an important issue."

Best Coverage of Minority Issues—This prize is awarded to the story that best addresses the issues and challenges faced by any minority group: racial, sexual, even religious.
First Place: "Underground or Over the Top? Critics Say the Message of Underground Railroad Museum Might Be Co-opted by Corporate Influence," Hans Johnson, Cincinnati CityBeat. Judges' Comments: "Clear look at the issues behind the issue. It's relevant to look where we're going based on where we've been."
Second Place: "Churches Face Rash of Empty Pulpits," Charita M. Goshay, Canton Repository. Judges' Comments: "A great look an an issue by a reporter who dug around and found the news."

Best Criminal Justice Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best reporting on crime or a law enforcement issue.
First Place: "A Seven Year Lesson," Sharon Turco, Lorain Morning Journal. Judges' Comments: "Beautifully written, sensitive account of a teen-ager's criminal mistake and the legal system's failure."
Second Place: "Sexual Predators," Dan Horn, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "Great enterprise reporting goes beyond the usual statistics and government agency quotes."

Best Social Justice Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best reporting on a social justice issue (poverty, welfare).
First Place: "Welfare to Work," Tom Ford, Crain's Cleveland Business. Judges' Comments: "Researched, thorough and well-written."
Second Place: "From Welfare to Work," Laurie Petrie, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "Nice work."

Best Explanatory Journalism—This prize is awarded to the best explanation to the reader of a complex topic.
First Place: "The Road to Freedom: Retracing the Underground Railroad," Michael Clark, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "A compelling story, nicely linking the past with the present."
Second Place: "To Abate, or Not To Abate?," Cindy Barber and Marianne Salcetti, Cleveland Free Times. Judges' Comments: "Admirable job of making a dry tax topic readable and relevant."

Best Editorial Page Campaign—This prize is awarded to the best effort by an editorial page to correct an inadequacy at the state or local level.
First Place: "Ohiogate is for Real: The Paul Mifsud Story," Columbus Alive. Judges' Comments: "Fun example in a series of editorials of a persistent, diligent effort to expose sleaze and dishonesty in the handling of the people's business, complete with satisfying results."
Second Place: "Nursing Home Accountability," Indianapolis News. Judges' Comments: "Convincing, knowledgable campaign."

Best Media Criticism—This prize is awarded to the best reporting on a media controversy or shortcoming of the press.
First Place: "Barometric Blowhards: Why the Viewers Can't Trust the Local Weathercasters," Felix Winternitz, Cincinnati CityBeat. Judges' Comments: "This and other 'Press Clip' columns show a depth of knowledge of Cincinnati, state and national media."
Second Place: "Remaking WGUC," Mary Ellyn Hutton, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "A tough placing to judge because of the two dozen such qualified entries. This story, however, held our interest. It explains the plight of public radio in Cincinnati."

Best Coverage of Government—This prize is awarded to the best story, or selection of stories, on city, county or state government.
First Place: "Loveland's Gadfly: Is He the Model of Good Citizenship, or a Pain in the Neck?," Skip Tate, Cincinnati Magazine. Judges' Comments: "Well-placed quotes, multiple sources and smooth transitions make this effective story-telling."
Second Place: "Health Care Reform," Michael Collins, The Kentucky Post. Judges' Comments: "Anecdotal lead effectively humanizes a complex topic, supplemented with solid reporting. Not overly jargon-filled."

Best Human Interest Writing—This prize is awarded to the best single human interest feature.
First Place: "A River of Tears," Dan Horn, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "A look into the lives of people affected by the flood. The reporting and writing makes your heart ache."
Second Place: "Portrait of a Killer: Michael Scott's Descent Into Madness," Paul A. Long, The Kentucky Post. Judges' Comments: "Compelling story, compellingly told."

Best Personality Profile—This prize is awarded to the best single personality profile published in 1997.
First Place: "Cleveland's Feagler," Paul Daugherty, Ohio Magazine. Judges' Comments: "You needn't have read Dick Feagler's columns in the Cleveland Plain Dealer for the past 25 years to know him and his work. Paul Daugherty's profile can do that."
Second Place: "Jonathan Rosenbaum," Mark Niquette, The Youngstown Vindicator. Judges' Comments: "The writer paints a clear portrait of an aggressive and uncompromising special prosecutor. Niquette's effort was made all the more difficult because Rosenbaum refused to cooperate. Accusing Niquette of invading his privacy, Rosenbaum hangs up with the words, 'I'm trying to save your crappy community.'"

Best Business Coverage—This prize is awarded for the best business reporting (story or series).
First Place: "Electric Deregulation: Power to the People," Kristen Baird, Crain's Cleveland Business. Judges' Comments: "Excellent explanation and interpretation of a very difficult subject."
Second Place: "Delaware County in Top 10 in 'Hot Growth' Study," Dan Crawford, Business First (Columbus). Judges' Comments: "Comprehensive and meaningful treatment of a topic of critical local importance."

Best Sports Coverage—This prize is awarded to the best sports reporting (story or series).
First Place: "Derrel Thomas: Drugs Haunt Reds Minor-League Manager," Mike Bass, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "Good reporting ."
Second Place: "Sour Grapes," Mark Winegardner, Cleveland Free Times. Judges' Comments: "An interesting approach to looking at the World Series loss."

Best Arts Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best coverage (story or series) of an arts/entertainment topic.
First Place: "The Ska Is the Limit," Mike Breen, Cincinnati CityBeat. Judges' Comments: "The writing and reporting on this next big musical trend kept our interest to the last word."
Second Place: "Once More, With Feeling," Linda Vaccariello, Cincinnati Magazine. Judges' Comments: "Interesting profile of a person, a new artistic director, and an enity, the Ballet."

Best Headline Writing—This prize is awarded to the best headline.
First Place: "His Honor in Question, Judge Cedes," Patricia Vuletich, The Youngstown Vindicator. Judges' Comments: "Nice word play that tells a lot. Much better on this story than a hard news head."
Second Place: "Tomato Top Banana of Miracle Foods," John Seney, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "Creative approach. 'Tomato' tells readers so much, and makes you WANT to read."

Best Web Site—This prize is awarded to the best single World Wide Web site run by a publication.
First Place: "www.citybeat.com," John Fox and Sean Hughes, Cincinnati CityBeat. Judges' Comments: "Terrific."
Second Place: "www.crainscleveland.com," Chris Thompson, Mark Dodosh and Andy Gebby, Crain's Cleveland Business. Judges' Comments: "A valuable resource."

Best Use of Public Record—This prize is awarded to the best use of the public record in researching a story.
First Place: "Ed Flask: The Invisible Man," Mark Niquette and David Skolnick, The Youngstown Vindicator. Judges' Comments: "The most competitive entry, this story is to be lauded."
Second Place: "The Charity Trap," Randy Ludlow, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "Strong use of official records helped present a picture of inequities in soliciting donations."

Best Daily Newspaper—This prize is awarded to the best issue of a daily newspaper published in 1997.
Winner: The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "The Beacon Journal has a solid and broad approach with great appreciation of artful makeup and appropriate generous use of space. Its front page on this randomly picked date was a top-notch mix of compelling human interest stories, hard news and the beginning of an indepth race series. The local section delivered like it should, (as did) sports and business."

Best Reporter in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of reportage by a single journalist in 1997. Judges looked for an extraordinary portfolio that included a variety of deadline and non-deadline reporting, a balance of breaking news and feature writing that, above all, evidenced a reporter who brings a "human touch" to her/his storytelling craft.
Winner: Rita Price, The Columbus Dispatch. Judges' Comments: "Interesting group of stories. ... Great leads. ... Tells a good story."

Best Columnist in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of columns in the state.
Winner: Roberta de Boer, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "A great variety of topics and great writing. Read every word."

Best Critic in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of criticism (movie reviews, restaurant reviews, theater reviews, etc.).
Winner (tie): Frank Gabrenya, Film Critic, The Columbus Dispatch. Judges' Comments: "Fascinating clips and great leads."
Winner (tie): Sally Vallongo, Arts Critic, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "A sophisticated writing style that isn't TOO sophisticated for the average reader."

Best Photographer in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of photographs by a single photographer.
Winner: Lisa Dutton, The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "This set of photos could have won first place in any circulation division. There is a great ability to capture the critical moment with this photographer's work."

Best Graphic Designer in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of page design and/or art illustration by a single graphic artist.
Winner: Rick Steinhauser, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "Steinhauser shows a range of techniques used appropriately according to content. His infographic on the soap-box derby was especially imaginative."

Best Defense of Literacy—This prize is awarded to the publication that best served the cause of literacy in 1997. The award may be for a published story, or for a community project conducted by the publication.
Winner: "Turning the Page," Cheryl Curry, The Akron Beacon Journal. Judges' Comments: "A series spotlighting adults who are learning to read. We hope these stories, which are compellingly told, will inspire others."

Best Defense of the First Amendment—This prize is awarded to the publication that best served the First Amendment during 1997. The prize may be awarded to an actual published story or editorial, but a legal action pursued by a news organization would qualify as would any campaign against censorship.
Winner: The Toledo Blade. Judges' Comments: "It is not unusual for a newspaper to battle for access when the stakes are high. The anticipated outcome justifies the legal fees and stress. But The Blade in Toledo fought when the stakes were low to preserve cherished constitutional principles. A Blade photographer had his film confiscated by police at a crash site. While his film contained, by the Blade's own admission, dull material the newspaper would never actually use, the newspaper nonetheless battled in federal court for return of the film."

Best Special Section—This prize is awarded to the best special section or insert published during 1997 on any topic.
Winner: "The Faces of Franklinton: 1797-1997," The Columbus Dispatch, Steve Wright reporter, Tim Revell photographer, Carol Ann Lease and Mary Lynn Plageman, editors, Victor Vaughan, photo editor, Scott Minister, art director, Tom Baker, Doug Miller and Tricia Barry, artists/design, Dave Stephenson, research. Judges' Comments: "Reporting, writing and photos combine in an excellent profile of a community."

Best Publication—This prize is awarded to the best free-standing publication published during 1997 on any topic. The entry must be a free-standing publication (such as a reprint, a book or other editorial product, and not a section that appears inside a newspaper).
Winner (tie): "Flawed and Sometimes Deadly: Military Medicine System Leaves Lives Shattered by Substandard Care," The Dayton Daily News, Russell Carollo and Jeff Nesmith (reporters), John Erickson and Andy Alexander (editors), Skip Peterson and Rick McKay (photographers), John Hancock, Lee Waigand, Mike Goheen and Key Metts (design). Judges' Comments: "Great journalism looking at some real tragedies."
Winner (tie): "Suburban Sprawl: The Changing Valley," The Dayton Daily News, Kevin Lamb, Dale Dempsey, Jim Bebbington, Steve Bennish, Dave Kepple, Cathy Mong, Derek Ali, Jim Babcock, Katherine Ullmer, Jennifer Inez Ward, and Bob Batz (reporters), John Erickson, Edwina Blackwell Clark, Carla Johnson Kimbrough, and Jim Van Dyne (editors), Wally Nelson, Bill Reinke, Jim Witmer, Marvin Fong and Jan Underwood (photographers), Jeff Adams and Bill Garlow (photo editors), John Hancock, Steve Spencer, Gregg DeGroat, Lee Waigand, Key Metts, Fred Kraus, Don Balduf and Mike Van Sickle (design). Judges' Comments: "An interesting look at a problem that plagues most cities."

Best Monthly—This prize is awarded to the best monthly magazine or newspaper published in 1997.
Winner: The Artist's Magazine, Jeffrey Lapin, publisher, Sandra Carpenter, editor, Greg Schaber, senior editor, Joanne Gilbert, ME. Judges' Comments: "The issue offered a fascinating look at 1997's best artwork."

Best Daily Newspaper—This prize is awarded to the best issue of a daily newspaper published in Ohio.
Winner: The Youngstown Vindicator. Judges' Comments: "We were impressed by the depth and breadth of this newspaper."

Best Reporter in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of reportage by a single journalist in 1997. Judges looked for an extraordinary portfolio that includes a variety of deadline and non-deadline reporting, a balance of breaking news and feature writing that, above all, evidenced a reporter who brings a "human touch" to her/his storytelling craft.
Winner (tie): Dan Horn and Michael D. Clark, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "Excellent reporting and writing. We couldn't put down Dan Horn's stories, but Michael Clark also shows great diversity in the types of stories and writing styles."

Best Columnist in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of columns in the state.
Winner: Rob Daumeyer, Cincinnati Business Courier. Judges' Comments: "Very readable columns on a variety of topics. Once we started reading, we couldn't put them down."

Best Critic in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of criticism (movie reviews, restaurant reviews, theater reviews, etc.).
Winner: Selected cinema and arts columns, Kim Leddy, Columbus Alive. Judges' Comments: "This critic is in a class of her own. She is versatile and has an ability to truly converse with her readers. This is wonderful work."

Best Photographer in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of photographs by a single photographer.
Winner: Bruce Crippen, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "Photographer works to illuminate the human condition. This portfolio is far superior (to other entrants)."

Best Graphic Designer in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of page design and/or art illustration by a single graphic artist.
Winner: Michael Brugh, The Cincinnati Post. Judges' Comments: "The work of Brugh is head and shoulders above the rest. His graphics are easy to read, informative and well researched. His double-truck Titanic graphic is bold, ambitious."

Best Defense of the First Amendment—This prize is awarded to the publication that best served the First Amendment during 1997. The prize may be awarded to an actual published story or editorial, but a legal action pursued by a news organization would also qualify as would any campaign against censorship.
Winner: Staff of the The Miami Student, Miami University, Oxford, Ohio. Judges' Comments: "The Miami Student is the winner for its fight for release of student disciplinary records. To fight the established order is a tough job even for an entrenched newspaper publisher. To do so as students requires extraordinary courage."

Best Special Section—This prize is awarded to the best special section or insert published during 1997 on any topic.
Winner (tie): "The Beverly Hills Tragedy," The Kentucky Post, Paul A. Long, John C.K. Fisher, Bob Driehaus, Frank Main, Peggy Kreimer and Jack Hicks, reporters, Michael Brugh, graphics. Judges' Comments: "There were some really strong contenders in this category, but this section on the fire provides well done coverage of a tragedy. The images are 20 years old, yet vivid."
Winner (tie): "Hall of Fame Extra," The Canton Repository, Jan H. Kennedy, Lori Monsewicz, Gary Brown, James F. Weber, Monica Davis, Charita Goshay, Dave Sereno, Diana Rossetti, Jennifer Mastroianni, Laural Karpanty, Dan Kane, G. Patrick Kelley, Steve Doerschuk, Kathie Smith, Saimi Rote Bergmann, Edd Pritchard, Don Detore, Mike Popovich, Mark Craig, Todd Porter, Bob Stewart, reporters, Michael Balash, Susan Shea, Bob Rossiter, Scott Heckel, Stan Myers, Cara Owlsey, photographers; Lewis Sagermann, Michael Weiss, John Barns, Al Szabo, Bill Snier, Meg (Peggy) Peretzky, Marc Munsey, Rick Whaite, Will Kennedy, editors and designers. Judges' Comments: "Lively photos and stories in these special wraparound sections during the Pro Football Hall of Fame festivities."

Best Publication—This prize is awarded to the best free-standing publication published during 1997 on any topic. The entry must be a free-standing publication (such as a reprint, a book or other editorial product, and not a section that appears inside a newspaper).
Winner: Ohio Cum Laude: The Whole Ohio College Catalog, James A. Baumann, Orange Frazer Press, Wilmington, Ohio. Judges' Comments: "Quite informative."

Best Weekly—This prize is awarded to the best weekly magazine or newspaper in Ohio.
Winner (tie): Business First (Columbus). Judges' Comments: "Excellent coverage, attractive design, solid writing."
Winner (tie): Cleveland Jewish News. Judges' Comments: "A good read for an audience of any religious persuasion."

Best Monthly—This prize is awarded to the best monthly magazine or newspaper published in Ohio.
Winner: Cleveland Magazine. Judges' Comments: "A difficult category to judge, because all dozen entries were superior. Cleveland offered (the most) editorial snap — 244 pages of top drawer coverage."

Best Student Journalist in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of campus reportage by a single student in 1997.
Winners: Emily Hebert and Jennifer Markiewicz, The Miami Student, Miami University, Oxford, Ohio. Judges' Comments: "To fight the established order is a tough job even for an entrenched newspaper publisher. To do so as students (in their battle for the release of student disciplinary records) requires extraordinary courage. The principals with the courage are editors Emily Hebert and Jennifer Markiewicz, who took the issue to the Supreme Court."

Best Student Newspaper/Publication—This prize is awarded to the best campus newspaper or student publication in Ohio.
Winner: Spark Magazine, Lakota High School, West Chester, Ohio, Dean Hume advisor,Vanessa Kazik and Josh Theiss, editors. Judges' Comments: "Aggressive, metro class reporting. We particularly liked the teams of under-aged reporters who tried buying cigarettes at local businesses near the school. And then named names of those businesses that did sell to minors. School censorship and homosexuality are also professionally addressed."

BEST TELEVISION WINNERS
Back to index

Best Investigative Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best example of investigative reporting in the public interest, either in a single aired report or a series.
First Place: "Las Vegas Junket," Laure Quinlivan and Jeffrey Keene, WCPO Cincinnati. Judges' Comments: "A complete package that is a textbook example of outstanding investigative reporting. Solid use of undercover footage, public documents and interviews. Got results."
Second Place: "Nobody's Pet," Reg Chapman, James Robinson and Laura Reed, WHIO Dayton. Judges' Comments: "This report tackled an emotional topic with research and good reporting. The heartbreaking video of the dogs being killed was graphic and effective, but not sensationalized. The series resulted in some immediate and major changes at the animal shelter."

Best Coverage of Children's Issues—This prize is awarded to the TV report that best serves the needs of children, either by exposing an abuse or exploring solutions to challenges faced by youth.
First Place: "Moyamoya," Gina Germani, WXIX Cincinnati. Judges' Comments: "Sensitive, but factual treatment of scary health issue."
Second Place: "Sex, Lies & Children," Cheryl McHenry, WHIO Dayton. Judges' Comments: "Nice job."

Best Coverage of the Environment—This prize is awarded to the TV report that best serves to improve the environment, either by pointing out a trouble spot or otherwise spotlighting an ecological topic.
First Place: "Deer Controversy in Cleveland Metroparks," Susan Davies, WEWS Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "This is a fine account of an environmental issue that often becomes very emotional. It's especially notable for its balance in presenting both sides of the issue, something not always found in this type of story."

Best Consumer Reporting—This prize is awarded to the TV report that best informs viewers about a consumer product flaw or danger, or otherwise befriends the consumer.
First Place: "Grocery Inspections," Deborah Cole, WLWT Cincinnati. Judges' Comments: "Wow! This is a thorough look at food inspections at various levels that is truly informative. Too many series on this topic go for the sensational "findings" that do little more than frighten the viewer. Cole obviously did much research and effectively uses interviews, demonstrations and information to make her points and convey useful information. An excellent public service series."
Second Place: "Quick Turn," Paul Herdtner, WHIO Dayton. Judges' Comments: "Well done look at one of the newest get-rich-quick schemes, real estate ownership with little or no cash outlay. These pieces were especially effective because the reporter was able to interview the course founder. The explanation of leasing was made easy to understand."

Best Social Justice Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best TV reporting on a social justice issue (poverty, welfare).
First Place: "Shepherd in the City," Dick Russ, Herb Thomas, Belinda Prinz, Matthew Rafferty, Terry Trakas, WJW Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "A rare look at a local spiritual leader's impact in inspiring community members to reach out and work for justice."

Best Education Coverage—This prize is awarded to the best TV report about education.
First Place: "Operation Education," Robert Busby and Courtis Fuller, WLWT Cincinnati. Judges' Comments: "The two reporters are to be commended for spearheading a drive to update the public on what is happening in education."

Best Coverage of Government—This prize is awarded to the best TV report or reports on city, county or state government.
First Place: "Wastebusters," Jim Otte and Jeff Guerini, WJW Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Well done, well told, well researched."

Best Human Interest Coverage—This prize is awarded to the best single human interest feature aired.
First Place: "Final Mission," Bill Sheil and Dave Arnold, WEWS Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "This is a gripping and moving account of the successful search for a dead World War II pilot's remains. A beautiful piece of storytelling done through a combination of good writing, excellent photography, solid interviews and judicious editing."
Second Place: "On His Own," Tom Merriman and Mark Durdak, WEWS Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "This is a disturbing, yet riveting, look at a throwaway kid. The audience can't help but wonder, and perhaps even care, about Anthony."

BEST RADIO WINNERS
Back to index

BEST OF SHOW/RADIO
Best News Operation—This prize is awarded to a television station based on the station's body of work from throughout the year. The entry can include newscasts, special reports, public affairs and other programming.
Winner: Staff, WHIO Dayton. Judges' Comments: "It's clear WHIO works very hard to serve its community: Good enterprise, good use of reporters. The station does its work on presenting a complete picture of the day's events in Dayton."

Best Newscast—This prize is awarded to a single television station in Ohio for a best newscast (based on a randomly selected evening).
Winner: Staff, WCPO Cincinnati. Judges' Comments: "Thoroughly professional."

Best Reporter in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of television reportage by a single journalist in 1997. Judges looked for an extraordinary portfolio that included a variety of deadline and non-deadline reporting, a balance of breaking news and feature writing that, above all, evidenced a reporter who brings a "human touch" to her/his storytelling craft.
Winner (tie): Tom Merriman, WEWS Cleveland, and Terry Daniels, WLWT Cincinnati. Judges' Comments: "The Merriman composite is very impressive. Well researched, aggressive, creatively produced reporting. Daniels provides excellent, informative, clearly delivered live reporting. Personable and credible."

Best TV Videographer in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of video shot by a single videographer.
Winner: Ali Ghanbari, WJW Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Outstanding work. Even mundane stories are shot with flair and creativity. Great."

Best Defense of the First Amendment—This prize is awarded to the television station that best served the First Amendment during 1997. The prize may be awarded to an actual aired story or editorial, but a legal action pursued by a news organization would also qualify as would any campaign against censorship.
Winner: "Ayran Nation," Don Mills, WHIO Dayton. Judges' Comments: "An even-handed report on the activity of a hate group, presenting all sides. A good example of freedom of speech and the press."

Best Public Affairs Program—This prize is awarded to the best single public affairs program in 1997.
Winner (tie): "Kids in Crisis: A Search for Answers," Tom Merriman, Bill Sheil, Paula Morrison Jones and Ted Hart, WEWS Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Comprehensive and thought-provoking, this program also seeks answers for saving kids in crisis. Use of community panel provides for a broad range of views and debate."
Winner (tie): "Floodwatch '97," Courtis Fuller, WLWT Cincinnati. Judges' Comments: "This is an unusual and uplifting program that shows how a community pitched in to help a flood victim. Good use of footage of both flood and volunteers. The show wisely made use of soundbites from volunteers, flood victims to help tell the story and what hope was brought to the flooded community."

Best Investigative Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best example of radio investigative reporting in the public interest, either in a single aired report or a series.
First Place: "Aging Series: The Plight of Baby Boomers and Their Parents," Maryanne Zeleznik, Jay Hanselman, Ann Hartmann, WNKU Staff. Judges' Comments: "Top-flight coverage."

Best Coverage of the Environment—This prize is awarded to the radio report that best serves to improve the environment, either by pointing out a trouble spot or otherwise spotlighting an ecological topic.
First Place: "Price of Water," Mark Urycki, WKSU - Kent State University. Judges' Comments: "An excellent example of environmental reporting on the local level. Good use of research and voice bites from interviews."
Second Place: "Mercury Standards," Kevin Niedermier, WKSU - Kent State University. Judges' Comments: "Interesting, well-researched look at a little known environmental problem and its potential impact."

Best Consumer Reporting—This prize is awarded to the radio report that best informs listeners about a consumer product flaw or danger, or otherwise befriends the consumer.
First Place: "Privacy Pirates," Karen Kasler, WTAM Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Excellent information, very well reported."

Best Coverage of Minority Issues—This prize is awarded to the radio report that best addresses the issues and challenges faced by any minority group: racial, sexual, even religious.
First Place: "Cleveland's Hough Neighborhood," David C. Barnett, WCPN Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "The highlight of this newscast. Good, promising subject matter."
Second Place: "Race Relations in Akron," Vincent Duffy, WKSU - Kent State University. Judges' Comments: "Would like to see more of a continuing report on this issue."

Best Criminal Justice Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best radio reporting on crime or a law enforcement issue.
First Place: "Polygraph Use in the Courts," Kevin Niedermier, WKSU - Kent State University. Judges' Comments: None.
Best Social Justice Reporting—This prize is awarded to the best radio reporting on a social justice issue (poverty, welfare).
First Place: "Welfare Reform," Robin Finesmith, WCPN Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Robin realizes that tackling an issue like welfare reform needs more than just experts, but also the views of those directly impacted by the change."

Best Education Coverage—This prize is awarded to the best radio report about education.
First Place: "100 Men Reading," Harry Boomer, WCPN Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Good use of sound and of choice of soundbites. An interesting story about an innovative reading program."
Second Place: "Evolution Warning Stickers," Vincent Duffy, WKSU - Kent State University. Judges' Comments: "Balanced report on a controversial topic."

Best Coverage of Government—This prize is awarded to the best radio report or reports on city, county or state government.
First Place: "Price of Water," Mark Urycki, WKSU - Kent State University. Judges' Comments: "A fascinating look at the politics of water. The series resulted in political leaders revealing 'deal' for water flow."

Best Human Interest Coverage—This prize is awarded to the best single human interest feature.
First Place: "Anti-Bacterial Products," Lorna Jordan, WCPN Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Excellent use of sound bites. Well written."
Second Place: "History of TV Dinners," Lorna Jordan, WCPN Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Fun knowledge. Snappy delivery."

Best News Operation—This prize is awarded to a radio station based on the station's body of work from throughout the year. The entry could include newscasts, special reports, public affairs and other programming.
Winner (tie) WTAM Cleveland and WCPN Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Station WTAM demonstrates effort to cover spot news at the scene. Serious commitment to coverage throughout the day. Well-produced stories. ... WCPN shows broad-based commitment to news, good analysis of stories affecting the community, plenty of on-scene sound."

Best Newscast—This prize is awarded to a radio station for the single best newscast.
Winner: "Clinton's Visit," WTAM Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Held together well. Good short, quick stories within. Well-planned and delivered."

Best Reporter in Ohio (Show of Work)—This prize is awarded to the best selection of radio reportage by a single journalist in 1997. Judges looked for an extraordinary portfolio that included a variety of deadline and non-deadline reporting, a balance of breaking news and feature writing that, above all, evidenced a reporter who brings a "human touch" to her/his storytelling craft.
Winner: Karen Kasler, WTAM Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Good writing. Economical choice of words packing a lot of information into very little time. No nonsense delivery, but with a sense of humor."

Best Defense of the First Amendment—This prize is awarded to the radio station that best served the First Amendment during 1997. The prize may be awarded to an actual aired story or editorial, but a legal action pursued by a news organization would also qualify as would any campaign against censorship.
Winner: "U.S. Supreme Court Turns Away Cleveland Homeless Grapevine," Robin Finesmith, WCPN Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Excellent content, delivery and subject matter. Quite enlightening. May the grapevine grow."

Best Public Affairs Program—This prize is awarded to the best single public affairs program.
Winner: "Lingering Legacies of War," David Barnett, WCPN Cleveland. Judges' Comments: "Solid use of period music, diary excerpts and current participants and experts."